Best Ice Cream Shops in The Bend
Favorite

What’s summer without visiting your favorite spots for ice cream and frozen yogurt?

From over-the-top shakes to classic drive-in ice cream stands, The Bend has a variety of shops for frozen goodness. Ready to explore your options? Here’s a guide to local ice cream options in South Bend, Mishawaka and the surrounding area.

The Black Cat and Meyers’ Ice Cream

Pizza and ice cream, all in one spot. The Black Cat is a longstanding favorite for pizza in New Carlisle, a charming small town. On the back side of the building, with a couple of tables to hang out, there is an ice cream shop that serves up all sorts of delicious flavors. So, dinner and dessert are covered.

RELATED CONTENT: 4 Reasons to Visit New Carlisle

Bonnie Doon Drive-In

Still serving up plenty of nostalgia, this old school Mishawaka drive-in is worth a visit. It’s well-known for sundaes and other amazing treats. Bonnie Doon is also considered on of The Bend’s best places to grab a burger, so we suggest doing both.

RELATED CONTENT: The Bend’s Best Burgers 

Caracas Bistro

Head to this Mishawaka eatery for great Venezuelan food but make sure to save room for the absolutely massive milkshakes. You’re likely to get one topped with a donut, ice cream cone and/or a piece of cake. No, really. They’re fit for two or more people to share.

The Chief Ice Cream

Tracing its roots to a small shop in 1962, the original location in nearby Goshen landed on a Thrillist list of the top 31 ice cream shops in the nation. The Granger location is a chip off the old block, serving up classic cones and fun flavors.

Dari Fair

Dari Fair, an unassuming shop in Mishawaka, found fame a couple summers ago when its Turtle Cone went viral online. It’s a vanilla soft serve cone with caramel in the middle, dipped in chocolate and rolled in pecans. Visitors have come from across the country to try it.

Let’s Spoon Frozen Yogurt

Think we’d leave out the froyo? No chance! Let’s Spoon is a wildly popular place with two locations in South Bend. They constantly rotate flavors and you can build your own concoction with dozens of toppings from which to choose.

PaddyShack Ice Cream

Cones, sundaes, floats, splits — PaddyShack in Granger has it all. This family run shop offers up hand-dipped options to a slew of regular customers. Some even say it’s the best in the area. We’ll let you decide.

Paleteria y Neveria La Rosita

Visit this shop on the west side of South Bend for a truly unique ice cream experience. The La Rosita crew makes their own paletas (popsicles) and is well known for the chamoyada, a fresh fruit cup with a little spiciness to it. La Rosita is truly a gem in the Westside dining scene.

RELATED CONTENT: The Bend’s Best Taco Spots

South Bend Chocolate Café

If you’re in downtown South Bend and looking for ice cream, this is your place. South Bend Chocolate Café serves up dozens of flavors by the scoop. You should probably game some chocolate to go too.

RELATED CONTENT: Get to Know South Bend Chocolate Co.

Vanilla Bean Creamery

Vanilla Bean Creamery in Granger offers up a ton of variety and generous scoops of its all-homemade ice cream. Some reviewers have gone so far as to say it’s the best they’ve ever had. Who are we to argue?

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by @abbywithherforks

Urban Swirl & Scoop

Urban Swirl built its reputation on soft-serve frozen yogurt and sorbets, plus milkshakes. There’s plenty to love from that collection. Now it’s also serving Graeter’s Ice Cream, a known brand across the Midwest.